Anthony's Pancake House

Stepping into Anthony’s Pancake House, you immediately sense the easy rhythm of a cherished local spot where mornings unfold at a comfortable, unhurried pace. Nestled on Montauk Highway, this family-run brunch haven offers a warm welcome, whether you settle inside among the bustle of friendly chatter or choose a sunny spot on the porch where a gentle sea breeze softens the start of your day.

The atmosphere here feels familiar and inviting, the kind of place where service is straightforward and genuine. Coffee arrives promptly, a quiet ritual that sets the tone for the meal ahead. The seating is ample and relaxed, accommodating both solitary mornings with a book and lively weekend gatherings with friends or family.

Here, the menu reflects a thoughtful balance of classic comfort and mindful variety. The pancakes—light and fluffy, sometimes enriched with seasonal twists like pumpkin or coconut flax—speak of familiar pleasures elevated by care and quality ingredients. Meanwhile, savory omelettes and hearty plates like steak and eggs ground the offerings in satisfying, honest flavors. Whether you’re indulging in a waffle sprinkled with fresh fruit or savoring a creamy eggs benedict with salmon, the dishes tempt without rushing, encouraging you to linger just a little longer over breakfast.

Anthony’s feels like a spot where the neighborhood gathers not just for a meal, but for a moment of connection — whether that’s a friendly nod from the staff, the casual hum of conversation, or the simple comfort of a table set with good coffee and homey fare. It’s neither flashy nor pretentious, but quietly steady, making it a meaningful part of Montauk’s morning rhythm.